SHIFTING GEARS
Review Scores (how we rate) Watch trailer →
A “back together” family sitcom built around a cranky widower, his estranged daughter, and an auto shop.
He Said / She Said
“I expected better quality from this experienced cast. It’s somehow both under and over acted at the same time, and that laugh track is ridiculous! It plays at some really inappropriate moments. There are a few decent topics buried in here, and I can see tiny hints of potential in some side characters… but it’s poorly executed.”
“Tim Allen plays Tim Allen, Kat Dennings plays pretty much herself, and the chemistry isn’t there. The pacing is a mess, the humor is forced, and the laugh track is so distracting it becomes the main thing you notice. If it had no sound, it might be better.”
What it’s about
Matt is a grumpy widower who runs a car restoration shop and hasn’t exactly been Father of the Year, especially to his daughter Riley. When Riley’s marriage falls apart, she shows up with her two kids looking for a place to stay… and suddenly Matt’s quiet, controlled life is gone.
The show plays out as a family reset: old wounds, clashing values, and an attempt to rebuild relationships while everyone navigates grief, divorce, and parenting, all with a traditional multi-cam sitcom vibe.
Overall vibe
“Sitcom with serious undertones” but not in a smooth way. It wants warmth and humor, yet the laugh track fires constantly (even during emotional scenes), which makes the tone feel off and the jokes feel forced.
Across Episodes 1–3, the rhythm stays pretty flat: cranky people being cranky, light plots, and repeated friction between Matt and Riley. Even when the show touches on good topics, the execution doesn’t land.
Episode-by-episode (1–3)
A prodigal daughter returns with her two kids and drops into her dad’s life (and auto shop) after years of distance.
Riley’s son Carter needs accommodations at school but Matt doesn’t agree with that concept and gets involved.
Riley looks for a job and Matt hires her to work at his shop, but things don’t go smoothly.
Content warnings
- Death of a family member / grief themes
- Divorce / family conflict
- Emotional distress
Critical reception (so far)
Reactions tend to focus on the familiar sitcom formula and the star-powered casting, with most reviewers agreeing the show is aiming for warm-and-easy comfort TV. The biggest criticism is consistency: the humor can feel forced, the pacing uneven, and the laugh track is frequently called distracting — especially when the story brushes up against heavier emotional beats.
Overall, Shifting Gears reads as “fine background TV” for some viewers, but a hard pass for anyone craving sharper writing, stronger chemistry, or a comedy that actually knows when to stop joking.
Who will love it / who should skip it
Will love it if:
- You like traditional multi-cam sitcoms with a laugh track
- You’re watching for Tim Allen / Kat Dennings familiarity
- You want simple, low-effort background TV
- You enjoy family sitcom friction more than plot
Should probably skip if:
- Laugh tracks are an automatic no
- You want strong chemistry or sharp comedic writing
- You’re hoping for depth or meaningful character growth
- You hate “cranky people being cranky” as a main engine