Escaping the Show Hole, one review at a time.

Paradise Review

PARADISE

Service: Disney+ First aired: Jan 26, 2025 Genre: Drama, Mystery, Thriller Episode length: ~45–60 min
First-Three-Episode Verdict

Review Scores (how we rate) Watch trailer →

Critics: 8.4 / 10
Hers: 8.5 / 10
His: 8.6 / 10
Poster for Paradise

A Secret Service agent investigates the death of the president in their seemingly perfect Paradise community.

He Said / She Said

SHE SAID
8.2 / 10

““I was immediately pulled in by the mystery and by how fascinating this version of ‘Paradise’ really is. The city is intriguing, the world-building is strong, the characters are interesting, and I’m invested in uncovering what is really going on. It runs a little slow at times, but the tone, the questions, and the whole concept kept me hooked.

It feels a bit like someone built a perfectly organized suburban HOA… and then quietly filled it with secrets, billionaires, and a looming sense that something is very, very wrong.””

HE SAID
8.6 / 10

“This show does a great job making its world feel both comfortable and quietly wrong at the same time. Every episode adds more questions, the cast is entertaining, and the political and class dynamics are more interesting than expected. It is a bit slow in spots, but the mystery, the atmosphere, and the hierarchy inside this society make it very easy to keep watching.”

Critical reception (so far)

  • “A slow-burn mystery with a strong atmosphere and a compelling central hook.”
  • “Polished dystopian storytelling that leans into politics, grief, and control.”
  • “Best enjoyed by viewers who like layered reveals more than constant action.”

What it’s about

Paradise begins with the death of a former U.S. president and the Secret Service agent closest to him trying to understand what really happened before the official story hardens into place.

Beneath that investigation is the real premise: What happens after the world ends?

Overall vibe

Dark, tense, and atmospheric. The show has a comfortably steady pace, but the mood stays heavy with suspicion, grief, and the feeling that something is always slightly off. It is more interested in building unease and fascination than racing from twist to twist.

Episode-by-episode (1–3)

Episode 1
Wildcat Is Down

A former president is found dead, and his lead agent Xavier starts piecing together what happened.

Episode 2
Sinatra

The investigation expands while Xavier starts to have suspicions about their community leaders.

Episode 3
The Architect of Social Well-being

Xavier pushes for answers from Dr. Gabriela Torabi as his distrust of the people in charge grows.

Content warnings

  • Violence
  • Murder
  • Emotional distress
  • Death
  • Child-related loss

Who will love it / who should skip it

Will love it if:

  • You like post-apocalyptic or dystopian stories with mystery at the center
  • You enjoy political tension layered into high-concept world-building
  • You prefer atmosphere, intrigue, and controlled reveals over constant action
  • You like stories about social hierarchy, power, and who really gets saved
  • You want a show that feels bingeable even while moving at a steady pace

Should probably skip it:

  • You want quick answers and immediate payoff
  • You are looking for a fast, action-heavy thriller
  • You get impatient with backstory and gradual world explanation
  • You dislike stories centered on wealth, power, and elite control
  • You need your dystopian shows to be more chaotic than polished