Escaping the Show Hole, one review at a time.

Younger Review

YOUNGER

Service: Netflix First aired: Feb 24, 2015 Genre: Comedy, Drama, Romance Episode length: ~22 min
First-Three-Episode Verdict

Review Scores (how we rate) Watch trailer →

Critics: 7.6 / 10
Hers: 7.5 / 10
His: 4.1 / 10
Poster for Younger featuring the main cast against a clean promotional backdrop

a 40-year-old woman pretends to be 26 so she can restart her career in publishing.

He Said / She Said

SHE SAID
7.5 / 10

“I know the premise is ridiculous. A 40-year-old woman passing as 26 is a big ask, like trying to sneak durian into a movie theatre and acting shocked when people notice. But somehow, Younger has enough charm to make me go along with it.

Liza is sweet, Maggie is fun, Kelsey brings good energy, and Josh is surprisingly lovely in that rare ‘is this man actually emotionally available?’ way. It’s not deep, but it’s funny, easy to watch, and kind of addictive, like scrolling TikTok when you only meant to check the weather.”

HE SAID
4.1 / 10

“The show has funny moments, sure, but the entire thing is built on a lie so flimsy it needs its own HR department. I could maybe accept someone fudging a resume, but this is a full identity reboot with the confidence of a person who thinks highlights and bangs can erase two decades.

Diana is the best part, mostly because she seems like the only person living in reality. Everyone else is floating through a very glossy fantasy where youth matters more than skill, experience, or basic common sense. It flows well, but for me it’s mostly fluff.”

Critical reception

  • Critics largely praised the show’s sharp, witty writing and breezy comedy rhythm.
  • Sutton Foster’s charm was frequently called out as the thing that makes the premise work.
  • Some reviewers noted the age-gap satire can lean broad, but the cast and pace keep it watchable.

What it’s about

Liza Miller is newly divorced, broke, and trying to re-enter the publishing world after years away. The problem is that the industry treats her like she has wandered in from a museum exhibit called “Women Over 40: A Cautionary Tale.”

After being mistaken for a younger age at a bar, Liza lets the lie become the plan. With help from her best friend Maggie, she pretends to be 26, lands an assistant job, and tries to survive work, friendship, dating, and office politics without anyone discovering her real age.

Overall vibe

Light, glossy, fast, and very sitcom-smooth, Younger is the kind of show that knows its central idea is absurd and simply moisturizes its way through the problem.

It has a publishing-world backdrop, a clear rom-com pulse, and workplace chaos.

Episode-by-episode (1-3)

Episode 1
Pilot

Liza tries to restart her career, gets slammed by ageism, and lets Maggie convince her that pretending to be 26 might be the only way back in.

Episode 2
Liza Sows Her Oats

Liza starts proving she is good at the job while still dodging the truth about who she is. Meanwhile, her attraction to Josh grows.

Episode 3
IRL

Liza and Josh grow closer, which makes the lie harder to ignore for Liza. At work, Kelsey chases a Swedish author, while Liza keeps balancing professional instincts with her exhausting new life.

Content warnings

  • Adult themes
  • Sexual content and references
  • Divorce and emotional stress
  • Workplace ageism

Who will love it / who should skip it

Will love it if:

  • You like light, glossy comedies with workplace drama
  • You can go along with a very unrealistic premise if the cast is charming
  • You enjoy age-gap humor and fish-out-of-water stories
  • You are here for Hilary Duff, Sutton Foster, publishing drama, or all three
  • You want something easy, bingeable, and low-commitment

Should probably skip it:

  • You need the premise to feel believable
  • You get annoyed when lying drives the entire plot
  • You want a comedy with deeper emotional stakes right away
  • You dislike fluffy shows that prioritize charm over substance
  • You cannot accept that a 40-year-old is apparently ancient in publishing years